Miley Cyrus Sued Over 'Flowers'
Songwriter Claims Copyright Infringement
Miley Cyrus is being sued for copyright infringement over her hit song "Flowers." The lawsuit was filed by songwriter Maede Martin, who claims that the chorus of "Flowers" is "substantially similar" to the chorus of her own song, "My Way." Both songs feature the lyrics "I can buy myself flowers" and "I can take myself dancing." Martin's song was released in 2019, while Cyrus' song was released in 2023.
Cyrus' Lawyers Say 'Flowers' is Original
Cyrus' lawyers have denied the allegations of copyright infringement, saying that "Flowers" is an original work. They argue that the two songs have different melodies, harmonies, and lyrics, and that they were written independently of each other. The lawyers have also pointed out that "Flowers" has been a commercial success, selling over 10 million copies worldwide.
Martin's Lawyers Say 'Flowers' is a 'Derivative Work'
Martin's lawyers, however, argue that "Flowers" is a "derivative work" of "My Way." They say that the two songs share a "substantial similarity" in terms of their melody, harmony, and lyrics, and that Cyrus must have had access to "My Way" prior to writing "Flowers." The lawyers have also pointed out that Cyrus and Martin have a mutual friend, who could have introduced the two songs to each other.
Case to be Decided by Jury
The case is expected to go to trial in 2024. A jury will be asked to decide whether "Flowers" is a copyright infringement of "My Way." If the jury finds that it is, Cyrus could be ordered to pay damages to Martin. The amount of damages would be determined by the jury.
Experts Say Case Could Have Far-Reaching Implications
Experts say that the case could have far-reaching implications for the music industry. If Cyrus is found to be guilty of copyright infringement, it could set a precedent for other cases involving similar claims. It could also make it more difficult for artists to use elements of other songs in their own work.
Cyrus' Lawyers Say They Are Confident
Cyrus' lawyers say that they are confident that they will win the case. They argue that "Flowers" is an original work and that there is no evidence that Cyrus had access to "My Way" prior to writing the song. They also say that the two songs are not substantially similar and that the jury will find in Cyrus' favor.
تعليقات